ABM Agency or Communication Agency?
Which one solves the problem you actually have.
They sound like two versions of the same thing. They are not. Choosing wrong costs an industrial CEO one budget cycle and, more often, a competitive window. A framework, an honest map of the European players, and one uncomfortable question most of them will not ask you.
| Alberto Regis · Founder, Alberto Regis & Partners · ≈ 22 min read · Original: Italian |
Every week an industrial owner writes me some version of the same sentence: “We’ve worked with a communication agency for years, but sales aren’t moving. They’ve now offered us an ABM project. Should we do it?” Or the mirror version: “I’ve read that ABM works in B2B, but our communication agency won’t hear of it — they say it’s the usual passing fad. Who’s right?”
Neither is entirely wrong. That is the problem. Because the choice between an ABM agency and a communication agency is not a choice between two similar tools with different names. They are two different crafts, with different premises, that solve different problems. A CEO who treats them as interchangeable is making the same mistake as someone who confuses an accountant with an auditor: they seem adjacent, both look at numbers, but they exist for completely different reasons.
This piece is for anyone sitting in the CEO chair of an Italian or European manufacturing company — revenue between 15 and 300 million, technical product, long sales cycle, few important customers — who has to decide where to point commercial and marketing resources over the next twelve months. It is not for marketers looking for academic definitions. It is for the person who signs the contract.
By the end you’ll have an operational decision framework, a map of the main European ABM advisors (with names, honest assessment, and where each sits in the market), and — if I’ve done my job — one uncomfortable answer neither type of agency will usually give you: in many cases the correct answer is not “one” or “the other” but “neither, not yet.”
§ 1 — Two different crafts, both called “marketing”
Same words, different grammar underneath.
A B2B communication agency, in the full sense of the term, is a supplier that helps a company build and distribute messages to a market. Its product is narrative: brand identity, positioning, website, editorial content, ad campaigns, press office, social presence, sales materials. Its natural unit of measure is audience — how many people saw, read, clicked, called back. Its internal client is almost always the marketing manager or the sales director, and results are evaluated in awareness, engagement, raw leads, opportunities opened.
An ABM agency, in the technical and not decorative sense, is a supplier that helps a company win a precise and narrow list of target customers. Its product is account penetration: intelligence, decision-maker mapping, orchestration of personalized touchpoints, measurement of the account journey, coordination between sales and marketing on each individual account. Its natural unit is not audience but the account — how many target accounts went from cold to warm, how many opened a dialogue, how many entered pipeline. Its ideal internal client is not the marketing manager but the salesperson — better if the sales director or the CEO themselves.
Put this way it sounds clear. In daily practice the two get confused because both do “content,” both run “campaigns,” both use LinkedIn, both talk about “generating opportunities,” both present dashboards. The vocabulary coincides. The logic underneath does not.
The communication agency thinks in campaigns. It has a theme, a rough target, a budget, an editorial calendar, a set of media KPIs. If the target is “CIOs of Italian manufacturers above 50 million,” fine: content is built that speaks to that category, media is planned that reaches that category, aggregate interest of that category is measured. The single account doesn’t exist as an object. The segment does.
The ABM agency thinks in accounts. It has a named list — usually between 5 and 50 companies — and for each one builds a dossier, an engagement-angle hypothesis, a contact sequence differentiated by stakeholder. If the target is Marposs, it doesn’t produce content for “precision manufacturers”: it produces reasoning that applies to Marposs, to their three business lines, to the three relevant stakeholders, to the last annual report, to what the CEO said in the last interview. The segment doesn’t exist as an object. The account does.
Figure 1 — Anatomy of two crafts: what they actually sell
| Communication Agency | ABM Agency | |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Narrative — brand, content, campaigns, press, sales materials. | Account penetration — intelligence, stakeholder maps, orchestrated touchpoints. |
| Unit | The segment. | The named account. |
| Metric | Reach, engagement, leads, opportunities. | Accounts warmed, opened, entering pipeline. |
| Internal client | Marketing manager, Marketing director. | Sales director. Or the CEO. |
| Cadence | Editorial calendar. Quarterly reviews. | Weekly, per-account. Co-executive with sales. |
| Time to value | Weeks to first campaign readout. | Six to nine months to first pipeline signal. |
| Fails when | Applied to hyper-targeted account work. | Applied to a fragmented mass market. |
This is the founding difference. Everything else follows: who pays for what, who works with whom, how long it takes, how return is measured, what kind of people are needed. Calling both things by the same name — “marketing agency” — is already the premise of every commercial misunderstanding.
§ 2 — What to ask a B2B communication agency
The infrastructure work no ABM program can replace.
A serious B2B communication agency does things that ABM does not do and should not do. It builds the company’s narrative infrastructure: the value proposition, the tone of voice, the home for content, the ownership of proprietary channels, the relationship with sector press, the visual consistency between website, trade fair, catalogue, brochure, and the email signature of the salesperson in Chile.
This work is indispensable and undervalued. No ABM program works on top of a company that doesn’t know how to say who it is. If a decision-maker at Ferrero opens your website and finds a definition of what you do that differs from what’s written in your German sales rep’s catalogue, the most refined ABM program in the world deflates in twenty-four hours. The communication agency is the one that puts the ground floor in order.
When you actually need a communication agency
When your brand is invisible or inconsistent. When Googling you turns up little, or old material, or three different versions of what you do. When your website is technically up-to-date but says what every competitor also says. When the brochure and the corporate deck carry different numbers. When your salespeople, questioned separately, define the product differently from one another. These are all symptoms that the narrative infrastructure doesn’t hold, and no ABM fixes them — ABM amplifies them.
When you need to occupy a market, not conquer individual accounts. If you sell into a genuinely fragmented market — a thousand small customers, low average order value, short cycle — ABM is oversized. You need category visibility, content that educates the market, consistent presence on channels where your customers spend time. This is the classic work of a communication agency.
When you’re building a new product line or entering a new sector. Before going account by account, you have to exist in the eyes of that sector. It takes a wave of qualified visibility: a serious white paper, a targeted PR campaign, an intervention at a reference event, content that ranks on a relevant keyword. These are communication-agency jobs, not ABM-agency jobs.
When you have a reputation need, not a pipeline need. You’re preparing for a sale, an IPO, a generational handover, an M&A transaction, and you need to appear a certain way to banks, funds, specialist press, industry associations. This is not ABM. It is institutional communication. Confusing the two in this phase is expensive.
When your salespeople need systematic support materials. Case studies, video testimonials, modular presentations, sector one-pagers, trade fair kits. This is communication work applied to sales. An ABM agency does it worse and more expensively.
The limits of the communication agency — the ones CEOs discover in year three of a collaboration, usually with a certain irritation — are equally structural. It cannot tell you which are your thirty most important customers of the next three years. It cannot build a one-on-one dialogue with the Chief Operating Officer of that specific company you’d like to have. It has no methodology to orchestrate five distinct touchpoints to five distinct stakeholders inside the same account. It is not organized to work at the tempo of complex sales (twelve-to-eighteen-month cycles, internal client meetings, sponsor changes, long silences). It doesn’t have the account logic in its DNA.
If you ask it these things, an honest communication agency will tell you so. A clever communication agency takes the project, labels it “ABM,” and runs it through its old machine. That is how ninety percent of failed Italian ABM programs are born.
§ 3 — What to ask an ABM agency
The surgical craft of the named account.
An ABM agency worthy of the name does the opposite. It does not start from your offering, it starts from your list of accounts. It asks: “If you were to close the year with fifteen new customers, which ones would they be? And why exactly those?” If you cannot answer, the first work is done together, and it’s called account selection — the most underestimated exercise in the entire discipline. The quality of the list determines the quality of everything else. ABM on a wrong list is ABM failed before it began.
Once the list is built, a competent ABM agency constructs four things per account:
An intelligence dossier
Not a LinkedIn profile of the top three names, but a strategic reading of the company: financials, declared strategic priorities, implicit imperatives, key stakeholders with their professional trajectories, recent public decisions, likely pain areas, possible openings. This is analyst work, not account-manager work.
A decision-maker map
Who decides, who influences, who blocks, who is already favourable, who is distracted. With their individual levers: what they seek professionally, what personal objectives sit under the company ones, what makes them visible internally, what puts them in difficulty. This work borders on organizational psychology.
An engagement angle
Not a pitch, an angle. Meaning: why should your way of seeing the world interest this specific company at this specific moment. Not “what you sell” but “which problem of theirs you recognize better than anyone else.” If the angle is weak, everything that follows is politeness.
An orchestration of touchpoints
Contact sequences differentiated by stakeholder and by time — handwritten emails, considered LinkedIn moves, physical mailings when they earn their place, content built for that account, invitations to moments designed for that account, coordination with the salesperson who owns the account. This is not automation. It is direction.
Around these four elements rotate all the others: measurement (which in ABM looks at the account, not the lead), alignment with sales (which in ABM is co-executive, not parallel), governance of the program (which in ABM is weekly or bi-weekly, not quarterly).
| ABM on a wrong list is ABM failed before it began. The quality of the account list determines the quality of everything else. |
When you actually need an ABM agency
When few customers make most of your revenue — and you want more of them, or you want to defend the ones you have. Pareto applied to portfolio concentration. If your top twenty customers make 70% of revenue, every single account carries enormous weight and deserves surgical treatment. ABM was born for this.
When your sales cycle is long, customer value is high, decision-makers are many, and the sale requires legitimacy before negotiation. That is most of evolved industrial manufacturing: automation, critical componentry, machine tools, industrial software, engineering services, complex systems. If your salesperson needs six months to reach the first useful meeting, ABM shortens those six months by doing groundwork the salesperson alone cannot do.
When you have already identified strategic target accounts worth a dedicated effort. An enterprise customer that would be a doorway to an entire sector. A competitor from which to snatch a symbolic client. A lost account you’d like to reopen. A supply chain where entering through one opens all. These are surgical situations, and ABM is surgery.
When you sell to complex organizations and you lack the internal capacity to map them. A group with eleven plants, eight directorates, three different governance boards: no Italian industrial company normally has the time and skills to make such a map alone. An ABM agency does it as standard work.
When you want to separate repeatable commercial execution from exploration of new accounts. The sales network manages what exists; ABM opens what does not. It’s a way to not overload your senior salespeople with prospecting they can’t or won’t do, without giving up on opening new accounts.
The limits of the ABM agency are just as real. It does not replace your category marketing. It does not bring you five hundred leads per quarter — if someone promises that, it isn’t an ABM agency, it’s a lead-generation shop dressed as ABM. It doesn’t work if you don’t have internal alignment between sales and marketing (in many cases the first job of the ABM agency is to mediate between these two functions, which is already half the project). It does not produce measurable results in the first quarter — anyone promising them is either lying or counting the wrong things. It costs more per account than a lead generated by a campaign: if you have a hundred accounts, ABM is wrong; if you have fifteen, it’s probably the only thing that makes sense.
§ 4 — Where the two crafts collide
The overlap that generates most wrong contracts.
So far the distinction is clean. In the market, no. In the market most agencies present themselves with labels that confuse. There are communication agencies that have added “ABM” to the brochure without changing method. Lead-generation shops that call “ABM” any list of targeted contacts. Sales consultants who call “ABM” their classic cold prospecting. System integrators who call “ABM” a software implementation.
The real overlaps, worth attention, are three.
First. A good ABM program needs content built for the account. Building it is a craft the ABM agency often doesn’t have internally. Some ABMs lean on a communication-agency partner for creative execution. It’s a healthy configuration, provided the direction belongs to the first and the second is the executor. The opposite — a communication agency attempting ABM by leaning on an external consultant for strategy — almost never works, because ABM strategy is not an addendum to editorial strategy, it is another grammar.
Second. A company that starts with ABM almost always discovers that parts of its institutional communication don’t hold and need to be fixed. It’s normal, and it’s adjacent but not equivalent work. Whoever leads ABM has the duty to flag it. Whoever handles communication has the duty to collaborate without resentment. In Italian practice this collaboration is rare, because the two functions see themselves as competitors rather than sequential partners.
Third. An ABM agency working on a client for two-three years ends up taking on roles that border on institutional communication: contributing to CEO positioning, training salespeople on the narrative, rewriting parts of the website, redefining the tone of sales materials. Not because it wants to expand scope, but because it discovers that without putting these things in order the ABM program doesn’t deliver the promised results. This is why, from the perspective of a mature client, a good ABM advisor ends up looking more like a strategic consultant than a tactical supplier.
The point is that the two machines, if they work well, integrate but stay distinct. If they work badly, they overlap and compete. The CEO’s choice is never “one of the two”; it is “who does what, with what role, in what sequence.”
§ 5 — The decision framework
Six questions, in the order they must be asked. Each answer sharpens the next.
I’ve reduced the reasoning to six questions that usually let me tell, in a first conversation with a CEO, whether their problem is communication, ABM, or something else hiding behind both labels. I present them in the order they must be asked, because one answer changes the next.
Figure 2 — Six questions, one order
1. How concentrated is your revenue?
| COMMS | Top 30 customers are under 40% of total. You’re in a fragmented market. Presence over penetration. |
| ABM | Top 30 customers are over 60%. Each account is heavy. Surgical treatment earns its keep. |
| GREY | 40–60%. Later questions decide. |
2. How long is your average sales cycle, from first contact to signature?
| COMMS | Under 3 months. ABM is oversized: no time to deploy its value. |
| ABM | Over 6 months. Systematic account groundwork measurably shortens that time. Above 12 months, ABM is usually the only thing that makes sense. |
3. How many stakeholders must say yes to sign a typical contract?
| COMMS | One or two. You don’t need multi-stakeholder orchestration. |
| ABM | Five or more. No mass communication reaches all those tables. Surgical, name by name. |
| GREY | Three or four. Depends on the economic weight of the single account. |
4. Who are your five dream target accounts for the next twelve months?
| NOT READY | Can’t answer in two minutes, or say “all large manufacturers in Northern Italy.” You need account selection first. |
| ABM | Answer immediately with five names, know why and who the main decision-maker is. Ready to start tomorrow. |
5. Will your top salesperson work four-handed with an external consultant on the accounts they own?
| COMMS | No — they protect their contacts. ABM is politically unworkable. Communication is a more realistic first step. |
| ABM | Yes — collaboration is real. ABM can land. |
6. Is your current strategic problem “become known” or “conquer specific customers”?
| COMMS | “Become known” — communication is the natural home. |
| ABM | “Conquer specific customers” — and you can name them. ABM. |
| GREY | “Specific customers” but can’t name any. The real problem is commercial strategy, not agency choice. |
If you’ve answered these six questions and land clearly on one side, the decision is made. If you land in between, the correct answer is almost always: start from communication (or the fixing of existing communication) and schedule ABM as the second step, not simultaneous. Doing both in parallel, with two uncoordinated suppliers, is the most expensive way to get neither.
§ 6 — The European ABM advisor landscape
London is the industrial centre. The rest is fragmented. A guided map.
The craft of ABM was born in the United States in the 2000s — the acronym itself was coined by ITSMA, an American research institute later turned consultancy — but it was in Europe, and specifically in the United Kingdom, that it found its industrialization. Today roughly forty percent of the world’s reference ABM agencies are based in or around London. It’s a fact worth keeping in mind when evaluating the Italian offer, which is still young and — with some exceptions — imitative.
I divide European players into five categories, because mixing them would mislead.
Figure 3 — The player map
| Player | HQ | Type | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Momentum ITSMA | UK | Strategic — Enterprise | Multi-year transformational programs |
| The Marketing Practice | UK | Full-service — Enterprise | Large B2B with ABM as one line |
| Transmission | UK | Full-service — Enterprise | Integrated B2B partner |
| Agent3 | UK | Executive — Enterprise | Data-led ABM at scale |
| Ledger Bennett (Havas) | UK | Executive — Enterprise | Enterprise with big-group resources |
| Strategic ABM | UK | Pure-play — Mid | Methodical one-to-few programs |
| Kingpin | UK | Executive — Mid | Tech B2B, value bracket |
| Modern | UK | Creative — Mid | Memorable, non-corporate approach |
| Alterra | UK | Strategic — Boutique | Intellectual partnership |
| Inflowential | UK | Boutique — Artisanal | One-to-one on very-high-value accounts |
| Bev Burgess (Inflexion) | UK | Independent advisor | Board-level authority, team training |
| Andrea Clatworthy | UK | Independent advisor | Enterprise CEO advisory |
| Marconomy | DE | Editorial + ABM | German industrial sector reach |
| SC-Networks / Evalanche | DE | Marketing automation | DACH B2B tech backbone |
| Alberto Regis & Partners | IT | Advisory boutique | Italian/European industrial mid-market (author’s firm) |
| Fifth Beat | IT | Digital B2B | Broader account lists, quasi-ABM |
| BizUp | IT | Tech B2B | Software companies |
| Terminus / 6sense / Demandbase / RollWorks | US (EU presence) | Platforms | One-to-many at scale |
Category 1 — High-level strategic references
These are the firms a CEO calls when ABM is not a project but a choice of commercial transformation. Important prices, long timeframes, executive-committee involvement, multi-year program design. They do more consulting than execution.
Momentum ITSMA (UK). The result of the recent merger between Momentum (British agency) and ITSMA (American institute that invented the discipline). Alisha Lyndon, CEO, is one of the global reference voices of the sector. High-level work for the likes of Salesforce, ServiceNow, Fujitsu, Microsoft. Their focus is transformational ABM — programs that redesign how a company goes to market on strategic accounts. For an Italian company with revenue under 500 million they are almost always oversized and very expensive. They are the reference standard against which all others should be measured, though.
Bev Burgess (independent, ex-ITSMA). The most senior figure available as a single person. Author of the reference book Account-Based Marketing (Kogan Page). Today she operates through Inflexion Group, a consulting boutique. Called mainly for program design, internal account-team training, strategic review. Doesn’t do execution. For an Italian industrial CEO she is the right choice when external authority is needed to convince a board, or to train an internal team that will then operate with other suppliers.
Andrea Clatworthy (independent, ex-Fujitsu). Led the Fujitsu ABM program, one of the European reference cases for scale and maturity. Today works as a consultant for enterprise companies. Highly respected in the practitioner community. Like Burgess, an “advisor to the CEO” choice more than an operational supplier.
Category 2 — Pure specialized ABM agencies, mid-scale
Firms that do ABM as their principal craft, with dedicated teams, proprietary methodology, ability to execute one-to-one or one-to-few programs on mid-market and enterprise clients. Probably the most relevant category for an Italian industrial CEO wanting to work with a competent international partner.
Strategic ABM (UK). Founded by Declan Mulkeen, one of the most visible pure ABM agencies in the UK market. They publish original research regularly, have a strong blog, and work heavily in tech B2B. Methodical approach, slightly scholastic. Good on one-to-few programs with ten-to-twenty accounts. Less suited to those looking for unconventional creativity.
The Marketing Practice (UK, with US and Australia offices). One of the largest B2B agencies in the world with an important ABM practice. They work for Adobe, ServiceNow, Amazon Web Services. Not a pure ABM agency — they also do demand generation, content, campaigns — but they have a strong ABM unit. For a large Italian company they can be a partner; for an industrial SME they’re out of scale.
Agent3 (UK, with international presences). Tech-flavoured ABM, very attentive to data and platform. Predominantly tech and professional services clientele. More executive than consultative — good when the strategy is already clear and you need a partner to orchestrate touchpoints across dozens of accounts.
Transmission (UK and global). Very large B2B agency with ABM practice. Like TMP, more executive than strategic. Important prices. Suited to clients wanting a single partner who manages ABM and other B2B activities in an integrated way.
Kingpin Communications (UK). B2B agency with a serious tradition in tech ABM. Less “brand” than the previous ones but operationally solid. Good value for money in the English bracket.
Inflowential (UK). ABM boutique with a more artisanal approach. Good for one-to-one programs on very few very-high-value accounts. They don’t have the machine for one-to-many programs.
Alterra (UK). Founded by Robert Norum. Small boutique but with important clients. Highly strategic, custom-tailored approach. Suited to CEOs seeking an intellectual partner, not a weight-based execution supplier.
Ledger Bennett (UK, now part of Havas). Historic B2B agency with ABM practice. Since being acquired by a large group it has lost agility but gained resources. Suited to enterprise clients.
Modern (UK). Younger agency, brilliant on the creative side, with growing ABM practice. Suited to those wanting a less “corporate” and more memorable approach.
Category 3 — Continental European players
ABM in continental Europe is less mature than in the UK. References are few, and often they are traditional B2B communication agencies that have added an ABM line. There are some exceptions.
SC-Networks / Evalanche (Germany). More technology (marketing automation) than agency, but with integrator partners who run ABM programs on German B2B fabric. Useful reference for those selling in DACH.
Marconomy (Germany). B2B publishing with attached ABM services. Very connected to the German industrial world. Interesting for combining editorial presence on sector publications with ABM programs.
In the rest of Europe — Iberia, Nordics, Eastern Europe — the landscape is fragmented. There are no pure ABM agencies of continental reference outside the UK. Italian companies selling in the Nordics generally use UK agencies for ABM on Scandinavian clients.
Category 4 — The Italian case
In Italy the craft of ABM understood as an autonomous discipline is young, and the players fit on one hand. Most Italian “ABM agencies” are actually B2B communication agencies, lead-generation shops, or sales consultancies that have adopted the label. It’s not necessarily bad — some do good work — but the CEO must know it, because they’re buying something different from what a British CEO buys when they buy ABM.
Alberto Regis & Partners (formerly IperLeads). ABM advisory boutique based in Piedmont, maximum six clients per year, exclusive focus on Italian and European manufacturing industry. One-to-one and one-to-few programs, no mass digital execution. The author is the founder, so party placement — the reader should treat this as a declaration of interest, not self-promotion.
Fifth Beat (Italy). Digital B2B agency with growing attention to ABM. More data-driven, less surgical approach. Suited to those working on broader account lists (30–100) with quasi-ABM logic.
BizUp (Italy). Agency specialized in B2B tech, with growing ABM offer. Good for software companies.
The other main Italian B2B communication agencies — Ranieri Communications, Extera, Rossi & Martin, Sec Newgate — have service lines that cautiously approach ABM without making it their main craft. They are good communication partners, less reliable as primary ABM partners.
Category 5 — Technology providers who also offer services
Worth mentioning for completeness, because they appear often in the market. They are not agencies but software platforms with professional services around them. Terminus, 6sense, Demandbase, RollWorks are the four main names (all American, all present in Europe). They primarily sell technology — platforms that collect intent signals, orchestrate advertising and email campaigns to defined accounts, measure the account journey. Useful for companies wanting to industrialize one-to-many programs on hundreds of accounts. Unsuited for authentic one-to-one programs, which require artisanal work no platform produces.
| Ask any player: “What did you do yesterday for account X that couldn’t be done by a generic campaign?” If the answer is vague, it isn’t ABM — it’s marketing automation with a list. |
§ 7 — Why Italian specifics matter
Five reasons a UK method imported unchanged causes damage.
The Italian market is not a miniature UK market. Anyone importing ABM methods from Britain without adapting them causes damage. The specificities are at least five, and must be kept in mind when choosing a supplier.
Figure 4 — Five specificities that break imported ABM
| 01 | The owner is in the room.Italian industry is mostly medium-sized, family-owned, run by the founder’s children or grandchildren. Complex-purchase decisions pass through this person in ways no Anglo template accounts for. Good Italian ABM speaks to the owner, not just the CIO or CFO. |
| 02 | Relational, not transactional.Italian commercial culture is more relational than British. Introductions from trusted intermediaries, the site visit, the dinner, the sector fair — they matter more here. Hyper-digital ABM works badly in Italy. |
| 03 | Less crowded channels.LinkedIn is still underused by most Italian industrial CEOs. A decision-maker receives twenty connection requests a month, not two hundred. Each touchpoint has a higher chance of landing. |
| 04 | Intent signals miss the point.The purchase cycle is shaped by factors no intent software captures: GM changes, family dynamics, succession situations, decisions made outside formal procedures, the role of trade associations and industrial districts. ABM that ignores them is technically correct and commercially useless. |
| 05 | Public financing as a lever.Industry 4.0, Transizione 4.0, PNRR, regional funds — they are a serious lever in Italian industrial B2B. A sequence designer who ignores these mechanisms loses a significant part of the engagement angle. |
These are five reasons why, if you sell primarily in Italy, a competent Italian advisor probably serves you better than a British reference agency. The opposite holds for those selling primarily abroad from an Italy used as a logistical base: there the British agency might be the right choice, or at least a necessary partner.
§ 8 — When the answer is “neither”
The situations where the choice itself is the wrong question.
There are situations in which the choice between ABM agency and communication agency is the wrong question. In my experience, and that of colleagues I compare cases with, there are three.
Situation one — You don’t have a clear offering
If you can’t say in one sentence what problem you solve, for whom, differently from others — no agency, ABM or communication, solves your problem. You need upstream strategic work, on positioning or offering, that neither does well by definition. Find a commercial-strategy or offering consultant, do it with an industrial partner, or put yourself in a room for a week with the right people from your company. But don’t hand it to an agency hoping it will emerge.
Situation two — The problem is organizational, not marketing
If your salespeople don’t want to change method, if your marketing is at war with sales, if the CEO themselves isn’t convinced anything needs to change — any agency becomes a scapegoat for an unresolved internal dynamic. Invest first in internal alignment. A change of CMO, a redesign of commercial objectives, a review of incentives. Then, when you’re aligned, buy an agency.
Situation three — You’re looking for a shortcut
“Send us leads ready to buy without us having to change anything” — the request every agency receives ten times a week. The honest answer is that thing doesn’t exist. If someone promises it, they’re selling an illusion. If you’re looking for it, the problem is not which agency to choose — it’s that you’re looking for the wrong thing. No complex B2B market rewards the absence of effort. Whoever wants results without change is buying advertising, not marketing.
§ 9 — How to structure the choice
Four steps that reduce the risk of a wrong contract.
If you’ve reached this point and decided one of the two types of agency really serves you, the operational choice runs through four steps.
| Step01 | Write the problem on one page — yourselfBefore talking to any agency, write — you, not a collaborator — a page that says: current situation (revenue, markets, customer concentration, pipeline), objective for the next twelve months (precise number, not adjectives), five target accounts or situations for the period, what you’ve tried before and why it didn’t work. If you can’t write it, you’re not ready to buy. If you can, you’ll be impressed at how quickly it separates serious agencies from those who want to sell a standard package. |
| Step02 | Talk to at least three suppliers, from different categoriesIf you think you want ABM, talk to a pure ABM agency, a B2B agency with ABM practice, and an independent consultant. Compare how they define the problem, not just how they define the solution. Distrust those who give you the answer before understanding the question. |
| Step03 | Ask for two similar case studies, with client names and people to verify withNot generic case studies, not “a client in an analogous sector.” If the agency can’t produce them, they have no relevant experience in your case. If they do, call the people. Half your judgment should come from these three calls, not from the agency’s presentation. |
| Step04 | Start with a small, defined, measurable projectA pilot on three target accounts, or on a limited communication campaign. Six months, not three years. With written objectives both parties sign. If the pilot works, expand. If it doesn’t, learn and change. Most disaster contracts — on both ABM and communication sides — are multi-year contracts signed on trust after a beautiful pitch. A good supplier isn’t afraid to start small. |
§ 10 — Closing
The choice between ABM agency and communication agency is not a technical question, it is a strategic one. Behind every apparently wrong supplier choice sits, most of the time, a question never clearly asked of the CEO themselves: what kind of company do we want to be in the next five years, and which customers do we want to conquer to be it. Answering that question is the real work. Choosing the agency is, by comparison, simple.
The most expensive mistake I see Italian industrial owners make is not choosing the wrong type of agency. It is not having yet decided, inside the company, what game they’re playing. A CEO who has answered this question chooses the right partner almost automatically. A CEO who hasn’t chooses badly, whichever agency they choose.
My advice, if I may give one at the end of a piece that promised to be neutral, is never to start from supplier search. Start from the real question, and take it into a conversation with someone — a mentor, an outside partner, a trusted consultant, a more mature owner — who has nothing to sell you. From that conversation, the right choice almost always emerges. The rest is execution.
| Methodology & conflict of interest |
| The author is founder of Alberto Regis & Partners (formerly IperLeads), an Italian ABM advisory boutique, and teaches Industrial Marketing at Fondazione ITS Meccatronica e Avionica in Turin. He has 30+ years of international marketing experience across companies like Danone, Quaker Oats, Scholl, Havaianas, Pivato, and in infrastructure projects in Pakistan and the Middle East. |
| The European player list is based on direct observation of the market, conversations with sector practitioners, and public material available at the time of writing. Some qualitative judgments on individual suppliers are the author’s personal assessments, debatable by definition. A CEO intending to use this article for an operational decision is invited to independently verify information relating to the cited suppliers, and to consider the author’s position within the category they describe. |
